Why is it important to fight child sexual abuse material?
CEO and founder, NetClean
We end this report with a reflection on why it is so important to fight child sexual abuse material. The following question is sometimes asked: Is it not just a picture, and does it really matter if someone looks at an image? For us, the answer is crystal clear.
Each image or video is documented sexual abuse of a child and depicts the worst moment of that child’s life. When the image spreads across the world the offense is repeated, again and again.
But it does not stop there. It is not a harmless act to look at child sexual abuse material. It is not something that you do, unless you have a sexual interest in children. There is a strong link between watching illicit material and sexually abusing children.
By detecting child sexual abuse material, we can find those with a sexual interest in children. The first step is to protect children from being abused and that’s why finding the material first to uncover the victims, is so important.
Michael Bourke works with sex offenders in the USA and has conducted several studies on the topic. Here he talks about the myth of the harmless perpetrator.
Michael L. Bourke,
Ph.D., Chief, Behavioral Analysis Unit, United States Marshals Service, USA.
The myth of the harmless hands-off offender
60-85 per cent of those who look at child sexual abuse material also commit hands-on sexual offenses against children. It is a myth that there is a large group of hands-off offenders that are no danger to children.
Years ago there were professionals – typically academics – who assumed there were two groups of individuals who are sexually attracted to children:
1) so-called “hands-off” offenders, who limit their sexual behaviour to viewing photographs and online videos; and 2) hands-on offenders. There was also a misguided notion that looking at child sexual abuse images would mitigate the urges of people with a sexual interest in children.
Same underlying motivations
Those professionals who worked on the front lines with sex offenders, however, such as criminal investigators, clinicians who treat sex offenders, and probation and parole officers, quickly learned this conceptualisation did not fit most of the offenders with whom they interacted. They realised the “groups” were simply based on the crime that had been detected by law enforcement and not on the offenders’ true criminal offense histories. Once they asked the offenders about undiscovered crimes it became obvious that the majority of so-called “online offenders” were, in fact, undetected hands-on abusers, and many convicted child molesters also possessed child abuse images on their computers.
In other words, looking at child abuse material and sexually abusing children are adjunctive crimes – they are different manifestations of the same underlying motivations or drives. Given that both crimes are “fuelled” by a sexual interest in children, the commission of each crime appears attributable to access and opportunity. Yet it is still not uncommon to hear arguments and read studies that describe differences between “hands-on” and “hands-off” offenders. In spite of several studies proving these conceptualisations to be fundamentally flawed, the myth is still alive.
Not a mitigating factor
Let’s look at the other notion – that looking at images serves as a mitigating factor. The first thing we have to recognise is this premise completely goes against basic psychology. In psychology, behaviours that are reinforcing (i.e., provide physical pleasure, satisfy an urge, cause relaxation) will maintain or increase the frequency of the associated behaviour. Thus, instead of mitigating urges, the viewing of child sexual abuse images will strengthen urges and enhance the fantasies. Child abuse images, like “adult” pornography, are designed to make fantasies seem more real. In the case of child abuse imagery, making those fantasies more “real” is precisely what we want to avoid.
60-86 per cent correlation
A number of studies have looked at the correlation between looking at child sexual abuse material and hands-on abuse. Michael C Seto, a Canadian forensic psychologist and author, is one of the most recognised researchers on paedophilia and sexual offenses committed against children. In his meta-analysis, a study that combines the results from all studies within a given subject – he found that more than 50 per cent, and probably closer to 60 per cent, of those who consume child sexual abuse material also commit hands-on offenses against children. This estimate may be low since a significant amount of sexual abuse goes unreported.
In a study from 2014 (Bourke et al., “The use of tactical polygraph with sex offenders”) 57.5 per cent of those in the study who had been arrested for a child pornography offense also admitted hands-on sexual abuse of children. This information was obtained at the time of arrest, and since any admissions could be used against the offenders in court proceedings, the researchers assume the percentage was an underestimate of the true correlation. The study was replicated in 2016 (DeLisi et al., “The dark figure of sexual offending: New evidence from federal sex offenders”) and in that study 69 per cent of the offenders self-reported contact sexual offences.
An even higher number was shown in “The Butner Study Redux: A report of the Incidence of Hands-on Child Victimization by Child Pornography Offenders” (Bourke & Hernandez, 2008). The researchers looked at a population of sex offenders within a voluntary, prison-based treatment programme, and found a crossover of 85 percent and an average of 13 victims per offender. At the time the paper was published there was criticism that the numbers seemed too high; the research was methodologically sound, however, and subsequent studies appear to support the “Butner Redux” paper’s findings.
In short, the idea of a “harmless” hands-off abuser is a myth. The studies show there is a high, if not very high, correlation between looking at child sexual abuse material and contact sexual offenses against children.
Ten important insights from the Netclean Report 2016
74.6 per cent of the police officers surveyed reported that their work load has become more demanding in the last…
The investigations and cases that law enforcement is dealing with continues to increase.
There is a common misconception that the children in child sexual abuse material are primarily from Asia.
P2P is not only the most common way to share material, it is also where the majority of the material…
As the use of social media continues to increase in society, the problem of child sexual abuse material being distributed…
To help tackle this, several Internet Service Providers have committed to blocking websites on the open internet that are known…
That work computers are used to handle child sexual abuse material is confirmed by NetClean’s customers.
The police officers in the survey highlighted a number of the challenges the face whilst working on child sexual abuse…
Female offenders are rare, but they do exist. Nearly half of the respondents in the survey, 47.5 per cent, said…
Almost two-thirds, 65.2 per cent, of police officers in the study reported that they, as part of their daily work…